There are several species of insects that feed on and affect root growth of Fraser fir Christmas trees either in the field or in seed beds. These include:
- May and June beetle grubs (Phyllophaga anxia, Phyllophaga fusca and Polyphylla comes)
- Asiatic garden beetle grub (Maldera castanea)
- Masked chafer grub (Cyclocephala sp.)
- Black vine weevil grub (Otiorhynchus sulcatus)
- Root aphids (Prociphilus americanus)
White grubs such as May and June beetle grubs, Asiatic garden beetle grubs, and masked chafer grubs are the immature stage of scarab beetles. Depending on the species, they can live in the soil for up to three years before maturing into the adult beetle. Grubs have a white C-shaped body with six legs and a yellow to dark brown head. Size of grubs can vary with species and with age within a species, as all grubs go through several molts before pupating.
Black Vine Weevils
The black vine weevil grub is similar in appearance to scarab beetle grubs, except they are legless. Occasionally they are also pests of seedlings. The adult black vine weevil is also a pest, feeding on more than 100 different kinds of plants with their preferred hosts being rhododendrons, hemlocks and yews. Adult weevils feed on leaf margins causing a typical crescent-shaped notch.
Root aphids feed on conifer roots for part of their lifecycle, then become woolly aphids that feed on ash trees. They appear as large white aphids on the roots. It is not known how much damage they cause to their conifer host; however, when numbers exceed one hundred aphids on a single seedling, growth of fine feeder roots appears to be reduced.
Root Feeder Damage
Grubs and other root feeding pests cause poor growth through root loss. Small roots will be absent and larger roots are often stripped of their bark. Young trees will appear stunted with yellow-green color. Mortality will occur especially following periods of moisture stress. Even after grubs have been controlled, seedlings that have suffered severe root loss from grubs often will not recover and grow properly. Seedlings that have had root damage in plant beds should not be planted out into the field.
Not all grubs will eat Fraser fir roots. Some grubs, such as the Japanese beetle grubs (Popillia japonica), only eat grass roots. Others, such as green June beetle grubs (Cotinus nitida), only eat dead organic matter on the surface of the soil at night. Green June beetle grubs can be distinguished from other grubs because they “crawl” on their backs when they are laid on the ground.
Another species of grub, the Oriental beetle grub (Exomala orientalis), has been found in isolated areas in western North Carolina feeding both on turf and hemlocks. In other states, it also feeds on Fraser fir. It is extremely difficult to control and any occurrence on Fraser fir should be reported to your County Extension agent.
May and June Beetle Grubs
Adult beetles feed on the leaves of hardwood trees, especially oaks. They mate and lay their eggs in short grass from May through July. Grubs are common in old pastures or where grass is kept short through mowing. During the winter, the grubs burrow several feet deep in the soil to keep from freezing. When the soil warms in the spring, the grubs gradually return to the root zone, feeding throughout the growing season. During the winter of their second year, they pupate and then emerge as adult beetles the following spring to begin the life cycle again.
Asiatic Garden Beetle
Unlike the May and June beetles, Asiatic garden beetles complete their life cycle in one year. The larvae pupate in late June, with adults emerging in July and August. The females burrow into the soil to lay their eggs (50+). Eggs hatch in about two weeks and the larvae begin feeding. Adults and larvae are found in the soil during the day.
Masked Chafer Beetle
Masked chafers also complete their life cycle in one year and overwinter as grubs below the frost line. Larval feeding activity will continue in April and May with pupation occurring in late May to early June. Adults emerge in early July. Eggs are laid in the upper 2 inches of soil and grubs begin to appear by early to mid-August. Larval feeding damage can be observed by late August through October.
Black Vine Weevil
Black vine weevils overwinter as mature larvae. However, a few adults also survive the winter to feed and deposit eggs during a second season. This weevil is parthenogenetic – there are no males produced and offspring are clones of the mother. Although one female was recorded as laying 863 eggs, the average number of eggs deposited by each female is probably about 200. The adults feed most extensively during the preoviposition period which occurs in late May and June and lasts about four weeks. Adults usually live 90 to 100 days. The adults hide during the day and are difficult to find. Eggs, deposited in the soil and leaf litter, hatch in 2 to 3 weeks. Initially, the young larvae feed on rootlets; but after the third molt the larvae move to larger roots. During their development, larvae molt five or six times within earthen cells in the soil. After a quiescent prepupal stage that lasts from 3 weeks to 81⁄2 months, the larvae pupate. Three weeks later, adults emerge. Adults feed at night and drop from the plant, feigning death when disturbed. These weevils cannot fly; so they must be carried or walk to uninfested areas. Problem areas are often localized.
Root aphids have multiple generations per year, producing live young. A portion of the population appears to remain on the fir host year round. In spring, however, many move onto ash trees, the alternate host, where their feeding distorts developing growth.
Growers often first become aware of the presence of root pests by above-ground plant symptoms, i.e., poor growth, poor foliage color, and even plant death. Most damage occurs on seedlings and transplants in plant beds, or young plants within the first year or two after planting in the field, though occasionally larger trees will be attacked. These same symptoms can have many causes besides root pests such as Phytophthora root rot, drought, or improper planting. To distinguish white grub damage from other problems, some affected plants should be pulled up and the roots examined. Grubs will eat the feeder roots and bark from primary roots, leaving little of the root system, although what is left may appear healthy. Also look for grubs in the soil where symptoms are found (see below). Root aphids are found feeding on the roots themselves. In addition, black vine weevil grubs have frequently been a problem in Fraser fir seedlings grown in greenhouses.
Proper identification of grubs is important. White grubs are often identified by the raster pattern, which is the pattern of hairs on the tip of the abdomen. With a hand lens, a grower may be able to distinguish between the different types. For positive identification, however, it is best to put the grubs in a small bottle in alcohol and send them to the North Carolina State University Plant Disease and Insect Clinic in Raleigh. Contact your local County Extension agent to aid in grub identification.
The adult form of many of these pests that feed on Fraser fir roots are nocturnal. Finding adult beetles or weevils is difficult. Many are attracted to lights at night and can be trapped in a light trap. Knowing when adults are actively flying can help time pesticide applications. Black vine weevil adults do not fly and they will hide during the day. They can be observed by placing a board or burlap near the seed bed to determine when adults are active and the size of the population.
Fields should be scouted for white grubs before trees are set. Grubs are difficult to kill because insecticides are often bound to clay and organic matter in the soil and will not move deep enough into the soil to affect the grubs. Grub control is improved if insecticides can be incorporated into the soil. This can only be done before trees are set. It is especially important to scout old pastures that are to be set in trees, as grubs are almost always present. It is not possible to adequately assess the prevalence of grubs in the spring since they may not have returned to the root zone. Fields to be planted in the spring should be scouted for grubs the summer or fall before planting.
To do a pre-plant search for grubs, select five locations in a one to two acre field. Select locations where grubs are suspected because of poor stands of grass (possibly due to grub feeding), wild strawberries (a favorite food of grubs) or where moles, foxes, crows, or other animals have been feeding on grubs. Otherwise, choose locations at random.
At each location, dig a square foot hole that is 6-8 inches deep. Sift the soil through your fingers, looking for grubs and keeping count of the number found. Grub size will vary from the size of your thumb to some no longer than 1⁄4 of an inch. These small grubs can be easily missed, so look carefully.
Record the number of grubs found in each of the five holes. Add up the total number of grubs found in all the holes and divide by five. This is the average number of grubs. If this number is greater than one, chemical control is recommended.
In the fall, incorporate an appropriate insecticide such as Lorsban (chlorpyrifos) in the soil along the strip where trees will be set. Only kill the ground cover in this strip. Leaving ground cover between the rows will provide a food source for grubs so they will be less likely to eat the roots of newly set Fraser fir transplants.
It is easier to tree seedling roots than to get chemicals into the soil to control grubs. Talstar Nursery (bifenthrin) is labeled for root dip at one gallon in 100 gallons (1.3 ounces / gallon). Talstar, which degrades within a few weeks in sunlight, will last for a year or more in the soil, protecting seedling roots. Be sure to wear appropriate personal protective equipment when handling pesticide-treated seedlings. This method of control can also be used when re-setting seedlings that have died from grubs.
Proper ground cover management is more important than treating with an insecticide to control grubs and to keep them from returning. Maintain a ground cover with suppressive rates of postemergent herbicides. Grubs that are already in the ground will have something to eat besides Fraser fir roots. All grubs will mature and leave within two growing seasons. By not mowing from May through August, no eggs will be laid in the field by the adult beetle to produce more grubs. Your County Extension agent can help you develop a ground cover management program for your trees.
Once trees are set, chemical control is much more difficult. Many of the materials for grub control such as Flagship (thiamethoxam) and Marathon (imidacloprid) work best when grubs are small. They should be applied in the late spring. These materials should be applied in 50-100 gallons of water per treated acre. Organophosphates such as Diazinon or Lorsban may give quick knockdown of grub numbers when used when grubs are close to the surface of the soil. This may be in the spring, or more likely in the fall. Apply these materials in the tree row before a soaking rain.
It is easier to treat for grubs in plant beds because the soil is looser and pesticides can be irrigated in. Sites for beds should be scouted for grubs before seeding and planting. When grubs become a problem, apply Flagship or Marathon in the late spring, or one of the organophosphates for quick knockdown. Irrigate into the soil after application as recommended on the label.
To control black vine weevils and Asiatic garden beetles, target adults before they lay eggs rather than larvae in the soil. Materials like Lorsban and Talstar sprayed on the soil surface will control these pests. For the best timing, lay a board or piece of burlap around the edge of the field for these pests to hide under during the day. Black vine weevils are typically active in late May or early June. Asiatic garden beetles are most prevalent in July and August but may be present even into October. Treat one to two weeks after adults are first observed.
Many growers in western North Carolina find that root aphids cause few problems. However, in areas where root aphid numbers exceed 100 per plant, and in areas receiving little rainfall or with poor fertility, root aphids may require treatment. Also, ants will actively tend to the root aphids to use honey that is produced. The ant tunnels dry out plant roots and cause further damage. Root aphids have been successfully controlled in other states with Flagship. If root aphids are found on roots of transplants, consider treating with an insecticide that can be applied as a root drench, such as Talstar Nursery. For current treatment options, and for help in determining if root aphids are indeed a problem, contact your local County Extension Agent.
Several weeks after chemical applications, scout fields to determine if grubs can still be found. If you see dead grubs on the surface of the soil after applying an insecticide, you have only killed the green June beetle grubs which feed on the surface of the soil on dead plant material at night. You may or may not have killed the grubs that are damaging your trees. Dig in the soil in several locations where grubs were previously found to determine if grub numbers have been reduced.
Publication date: Jan. 1, 2009
Revised: March 1, 2019
Recommendations for the use of agricultural chemicals are included in this publication as a convenience to the reader. The use of brand names and any mention or listing of commercial products or services in this publication does not imply endorsement by NC State University or N.C. A&T State University nor discrimination against similar products or services not mentioned. Individuals who use agricultural chemicals are responsible for ensuring that the intended use complies with current regulations and conforms to the product label. Be sure to obtain current information about usage regulations and examine a current product label before applying any chemical. For assistance, contact your local N.C. Cooperative Extension county center.
North Carolina State University and North Carolina A&T State University commit themselves to positive action to secure equal opportunity regardless of race, color, creed, national origin, religion, sex, age, veteran status or disability. In addition, the two Universities welcome all persons without regard to sexual orientation.